One of my desultory ongoing marketing activities is to sort of participate on a couple of forums in which budding writers seek help, support, guidance, literary circle jerks, and sometimes editing services. I don’t post often; I’m not good at being an emotional support animal, and most of the questions just make me shake my head.
Here’s the problem: most of them can’t yet write correct English. While I do not look down on them for that as people, the idea of attempting to publish material in incorrect or broken English is dubious. Here’s the compounding problem: most of the people proposing to help them don’t even realize that the querents can’t write correct English, because they don’t know either (including plenty of self-proclaimed “editors”).
At some point, it seems, not only did garbage English become the norm, but it became the norm for literary aspirants and those who propose to guide them. The notion that all writers should at least write in reasonably educated English seems passé–and few now even seem to know the difference.
Are some of them not native speakers? Surely many are not. Okay, fine; then write in a language in which you are at least fluent, if not perfect. I speak Spanish, not fluently; I wouldn’t dream of trying to write a book in the language. I’d be an embarrassment.
Do some of them plan to hire editors to clean up the messes? I hope so…but from what I see, most aren’t willing to pay what a competent editor would ask. Many probably couldn’t afford it. It comes down to the question: will the writing receive remedy before publication? I would say the answer is a hard no.
Could I help them? I certainly could…but not for the effective $5/hour they can pay a fellow semi-literate who claims to be an editor. If editing just means fixing all the things, why pay any more than Wal-editing rates? And since the writer does not know the difference, that self-proclaimed editor doesn’t have to be any good. S/he just has to be better than his or her client. This is a low bar to clear. I see some responses that I am not sure even clear that bar.
I have some examples for you. Over a period of months, I collected the following (nearly verbatim, lightly edited to sampleize without making the English better or worse) writer/”editor” questions and “editor” answers:
How many words should a chapter comprise of?
How can I make my new book a best seller.
Hi Guys a relative newbie to the editing world, I was just wondering do people advertise their prices on their website at all? [Yes. This person was asking an editing group in this manner.]
Is there any good blogging sits out there. Were I can make a little bit of money and just have fun writing about random stuff.
I’m a line and copy editor. I offer free edit for the first [x] words, contained in your manuscript. It will help you get a feel of how I work. [In response to a request for editing services.]
What good for a book cover please
Tips on how to write stories?
I’m experiencing panic attack right now! And the reason is one of my friend told me not to post any of your sad feelings now.
I am writing a historical novel. I want to add artificial characters and plot within it to beautify the story. Can I ? pls suggest.
How do you guys prevent eye strain from your computer when writing?
Do you believe that Writing is inherited skill (by birth) ? Or anyone can become writer ? What are the traits of a writer ?
How do you guys think I can become famous by writing.
Is it a good idea to publish a book when you have no money?
what is the shortest length acceptable for a chapter? the longest?
why we Cannot protagonist be evil ?what is reason behind this. Can main character be the antagonist ?
What makes a plot unique?
How many books have to read if one wanna to become a writer
I want to create a female character but I’m a male any advice?
Please my people, help me with the best means to market my book or with a good marketer. Please contact us for supply or to market the book with us or in fact any means of selling the book.
I’m not putting these here to look down on anyone. Believe that, if for no other reason than that I don’t need to and can’t gain from doing so. I’m putting them here so that those who have been appalled by the current state of self-published English writing can peek into the kitchen and even into the restaurant supplier’s processing plant. It’s not you. It’s them. It has gotten bad.
And if many of the editors (when an editor was even involved) are barely better than their clients, how could the whole thing avoid being a leaky mess?
This is also intended as encouragement to those of you who write. If you can assemble complete English sentences with the correct prepositions, and use them to make intelligent statements and ask intelligent questions, congratulations. You are probably in the 85th percentile of aspiring writers.
4 thoughts on “Why it’s hard to volunteer help to beginning writers”
Thanks for a peek into the kitchen of health code violations.
The self-publishing industry has devolved to a point where participation involves little more than uploading files to servers and proclaiming to be a writer for having done so. The resulting sea of sludge may eventually force a renaissance in traditional publishing.
I have noticed a backlash against social-media-like writing. Its ungrammatical brain-burp style of communication begot a collapsing of full ideas into sticker-length junk. Supposed experts pointed to goldfish-sized attention spans as justification, but readers who really want to escape are now looking for fully developed ideas again. They want to sink into real stories told in clear language–what a shock.
Maybe this will raise the bar for editors and writers alike.
Interesting theory about the potential trad-pub renaissance, Jason. Perhaps at some point the market becomes so flooded with unedited, unproofed, anyone-can-publish-thanks-to-the-Internet dross that it becomes less worth the effort. At the same time, trad-pubs have to take some accountability for their own quality declines. What is clear to me: if the author wants the book to be free of errors, the author will have to take the steps to eliminate them, because the publisher probably won’t.
May that backlash spread and become a cavalcade, because I am over the brain burps. There’s a forum on which experienced persons help novices estimate identifications and values of items, and my rule is simple: anyone who writes in unpunctated garbage-speak I just do not bother helping even if I know the answer. Basic respect seems to me to include posting the question in at least a somewhat literate manner.
“How do you guys think I can become famous by writing.”
Ransom demands, death threats, and “Give me all the money” can be a good start, if addressed to the correct entities.
Heh. That would work! Thanks for stopping by.